Thursday, August 28, 2008

THE BEST OF BOTH WORLDS...

...(Isn't that the Hannah Montana theme song? I think so)... Anyway....I am SO TORN! I want the best of both worlds in regards to Emily's schedule. I want her to be able to just fall asleep on her own, but then I love to rock, cuddle, and sing her to sleep. I want to have "set" naptimes, bedtimes, feeding times and waketimes, but then I want to be able to be flexible to go out or run errands if something comes up. I've been reading BABYWISE and incorporating the feed/wake/sleep thingy into our lives. She's pretty much on a 2 1/2-3 1/2 hour feeding schedule, and she's pretty good about having wake time after feeding time... BUT...she DEFINITELY has to be rocked to sleep...and then sometimes she wakes up a few minutes later and has to be rocked back to sleep.....and then a few minutes later......and then a few minutes later! AH! Tonight it took me like 4 tries to get her SLEEPING SOUNDLY. So, I don't want to play that game every night....BUT....I DON'T WANT HER TO CRY FOREVER EITHER!

I'm sure a lot of you have felt the same way...probably particularly with your first baby. I NEED YOUR COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS to know I'm not alone and to know what worked for you. I've been trying not to RUSH in and pick her up the second I hear a peep...like I did at first...(sigh). So we ARE making progress. But, it's just hard because yesterday I just let her cry for a little bit, then I checked on her and she had like GALLONS of spit up all over her face and neck and running into her ear! SAD! DUH! THAT'S why she was crying. Then another time I tried to just let her cry a little bit...I checked on her and finally picked her up and she burped like the LOUDEST burp (Like on ELF after he drank the entire Soda) and so I felt bad because those were ACTUAL DISCOMFORTING things and the REASONS why she was crying. TORN I tell you...JUST TORN! BUT OH how I DREAM of the day when she sleeps longer than 3 or 4 hours during the night! BLESSED!

How do people have twin newborns? When do the moms sleep? I feel like I feed this baby ALL DAY LONG. Can't imagine twins. BECKY AND LEAH HOW THE HECK DO YOU DO IT?

Can't wait to hear your comments...all you EXPERT moms out there! SO GLAD you all had kids before me.

Some happy news: In the mail we received the usual medical bills and explanation of benefits that we have so lovingly accepted and paid for the last 9 months. (Remember: My Doc had me in ONCE A WEEK for like the first 3 months of my pregnancy AND the last 3 months. Hence:lots of visits=lots of bills) Lucky for us though, I'm on an HSA plan-high deductible, and once it's met you pay zero dollars. Welp, the happy day came. We received hospital bills that looked like this:

$9,000.00 + hundreds here and there

the "Patient owes part" looked like this:

"Patient owes $0.00"

WAHOOO! FINALLY!


OH CRUD! Baby is awake. Attempt # 5 to put her "to bed" ...

17 comments:

Tawna said...

Oh yay! Whitney, honestly, this is the hardest part of having a kid. I'm in no way an expert...really, I wish my kids had a better mom...but with Maya, I too tried the cry it out for a few minutes, and then went in to find spit up everywhere (like you said). So then I just felt like a monster and wouldn't dream about setting her down again until she was asleep. So then I started to go in when she cried and just check on everything (binky in, no spit up, burp her if she acted gassy, rewrap the burrito-style blanketing, check diaper) and NOT say a word or smile--NOTHING. I'd then lay her down, pat her a few times, and leave the room. This seemed to work better for me. I did this for Brennan and by two months he was sleeping 6ish hours. Just to warn you though: there will be relapses (We're having one now)and they stink so bad! Just stick with it though and EVENTUALLY you will get some sleep. Remember that naptime is sacred. Don't skip your nap to clean, work out, etc. And that is my advice!

Candace said...

Ok, prepare yourself for a LONG comment....I had NO idea how big of a deal SLEEP was with babies until I had my first!! SO, I've learned a lot since then!

I just looked back to see when she was born and I see that she's almost 4 weeks old. In my experience weeks 3ish-6ish are HARD, all around! The baby is more wakeful, more fussy, more restless with their sleeping...just exhausting!!

With Hannah I was SO determined to not let her "cry it out;" I couldn't BEAR that thought! I LOVED holding her while she slept and sleeping with her. It was fine in those first couple months. BUT, then...it turned into a NIGHTMARE! I couldn't get ANYTHING done around the house because I had to hold her for ALL her naps, in a dark room, without moving a muscle. Then at night she would only sleep until about midnight and then came into bed with us. No one slept well. It was bad.

FINALLY, at 5 months I decided that I was going to have to go "cold turkey" and let her cry it out...it was SO hard that first night. HELL, it was. But after that, she slept 12 HOURS at night!! Naps took a little more work.

SO, when Mr. David came around I KNEW that I needed to help him learn to sleep on his own from the start. I still felt like newborns shouldn't have to "Cry it out" yet.

I did a little research and found a method that I was more comfortable with for a newborn. I got a CD that had lullaby music set to a human heartbeat (www.babygotosleep.com). It basically tells you to set a little before bed/nap routine (change, read story, sing song, etc.) turn on the music, hold your baby and get them calm/drowsy, lay them down, lay your hand on their back or stomach for a few seconds then walk out. If they start crying give them 2-3 minutes to figure it out on their own, then if they aren't settling down go back in and put your hand on their back. If they still won't settle down after 2-3 minutes pick them up, get them calm, then repeat the process. If they won't go to sleep after 3-4 rounds of this, just put them to sleep the way that works best (rocking, binky, etc.) then try again next sleep time.

Bascially, with newborns, you just have to keep trying!

Another thing is to try your best to recognize her signs of sleepiness (getting more calm, not looking around as much/not as active, yawning, rubbing eyes, etc.). When she gets to the point of major tired fussiness you've pushed her too far and it will be harder to get her asleep. Newborns can usually comfortably stay awake for up to about 2 hours at a time.

Tawna is right about the relapes; with infants and young children there is almost always a "sleep issue" every few months. I think it coincides a lot of the time with big developmental milestones (ie. rolling over, sitting up, crawling, walking, etc.) You just have to "stick to your guns" and you'll get through it!

ANYWAY.......yeah. Told you this would be a long one! I can't say I'm an "expert" but I've "been around the block" with all the different go-to-sleep methods!

GOOD LUCK!!

Brittney said...

Hey Whitney this is Katie's friend Brittney and I am going to give you my 2 cents and you can take it or leave it or take some parts:) But I have 2 kids that both have slept at 7 weeks 12 hours every night. My advice is I know alot of moms that cant stand staying at home and have "schedules" for their babies but it truly is what you have to do. I am a major stresser about schedules. Well I was with my first and with my second I have calmed a bit. My little girl is almost 1 and she still takes 3 naps a day and sleeps through the night. YOu have to have a schedule. It really comforts the baby. Honestly she is what 4 weeks and she should be taking naps every hour after she wakes up. My little girl goes down every 2 hours after each nap. Does that make sense. I am telling you babies will respond so much better to routines. I actually had to bounce my little girl for like 2 min. every time I would lay her down but once she knew it was routine she now leans for her crib and I just lay her down and she goes right to sleep. I also lay my babies on their bellies once they can lift their heads so at like 4 or 5 weeks I start laying them on their bellies and they love it!!! It makes them feel safe and when they flinch when they are sleeping it doesnt wake them up. I promise she wont suffocate. just dont have pillows or stuffed animals in their crib and they will be absolutely fine. So at night I actually bounced my little girl for just a few min. to get her drowsy and then I would lay her down. If she would wake up I would just go in their and pat her back but dont talk and then walk out. With my little boy I would go in every 5-7 min. and just pat his back and put his binki back in his mouth and then go back out. He would cry for like 45 min. but then after a few days he was sleeping through the night. his cry wasnt hard crying thats why I let him cry. But I promise if you keep a schedule and routine they will sleep so good for you. I have dont it with both kids and it has worked awesome!! If this is at all confusing you can seriously ask me any questions. Good luck though. I am not a new born stage kindof mom. Those first 2 months are very hard. Sorry this is so long too. Well and too my kids were both bottle fed because I cant nurse but I have heard from moms that do nurse and they say that they actually will feed their babies formula before bed to maybe fill them up better and for longer and sometimes even in the middle of the night. YOu want to get her used to both is what I hear. But try what you want I am just giving my opinions:) Good luck

Ryan and Chelsea said...

I think with Ashton we would put him in bed and let him cry for like for like, 2 minutes and then go check on him. Then wait 4 minutes, go check on him and reassure him that we were still there (without picking him up), then wait 8 minutes--you get the picture. you have to do this several times before they realize that you are still there and still love them. Some babies are just like that--they don't want to go to sleep on their own. But in my opinion it is better to do the tough love thing than to spend MONTHS rocking the baby to sleep over and over again. I know it is SO frustrating. You just want to sleep and you don't care about how it happens because you are so tired. You just have to be persistent. The most important thing is to be consistent and not to give in to rocking your baby once you have started this, or it will blow the whole thing. Good luck Whitney--this is so hard, I know!

Haymore Family said...

OH i totally feel for you, and seriously its good you are doing this now, because bryson was rocked to sleep until he was one! im so crazy and will never do it again! I loved to rock him when it was quick, but some nights it was like 2 hours! anyways, she probably burped so loud just from screaming sucking in all that air dont feel bad! and she might be to young to make her cry now to sleep, but in a few months she can. let her cry for a while and then go pat her back and keep doing that a few times and see if it works! she will learn!

Our Ohana said...

Oh the dreaded sleep issues! I was like Candace and rocked Kason to sleep and held him for all his naps when he was little. I think when he was 4 months old we finally had him start sleeping in his crib for naps! it was horrible! He would sleep in his swing too and that was a really hard habit to break.

But, once we did break the habits and he was going to sleep on his own he slept SO good! We actually did do "cry-it-out" - but not until he was 4 months old.

Another thing we did when he was little, like Candace said, was get a bedtime routine! We would do bath, bottle, book, songs, and swaddle then to bed. Swaddling was WONDERFUL for us when he was little!! We've always played music for Kason while he's going to sleep - it may become a habit but atleast it's an easy habit to deal with. And I know all the books say it but try to put her down when she's calm and drowsy. We did this with Kason and if he would start to fuss I would just go in a pat him stomach and kind of rock him back a forth in his crib - without talking to him or making eye contact or anything. But, I would also let him fuss a couple minutes before I would go in.

Anyways - this is totally unorganized thinking and I'm in no way a professional!! but, good luck - it really does get better - I PROMISE!

Hey - I'm curious about that HSA you guys are on. Is it through Brad's work?? Do they have health restrictions (like would Kameron be able to get on it with his lupus?) Anyways - if you know anything about it we're kinda interested in looking into one.

Jessica said...

wow. you have alot of comments on this post. i still dont have a routine (except bedtime) for my girls. thats probably why they dont sleep very well. addie still wakes up multiple times after putting her to bed. well sometimes i quess. not ALL the time. i remember though when she was little. i put a humidifer in my bedroom so i wouldnt hear her and wake up. she would wake up just to be comforted back to sleep. that began the begining of her sleeping through the night! fabulous. after about a week, she was a champ. and then after that, i put the humidifer in her room to drown out all the little noises. you are an awesome mom! your instincts are better than any advise.
we need to hang out!

Travis and Britni said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Travis and Britni said...

Hey Whit. I realized the 1st comment I left wasn't all that helpful, so I'm gonna try this again. You've received a lot of great comments. Bottom line....every child is different, so some of this advice will work, and some of it won't. But you know me.....I'm not shy about giving my opinion:) I agree with most people that swear by putting your baby on a schedule. However, I don't create the schedule. I let the baby set their schedule. Life is crazy, and busy and not always predictable, so having an exact time to when they eat and sleep can be difficult if something out of your control happens spontaneously. However, there is a schedule in place. Whenever they wake up, they eat, then a couple hours or so later they take a nap. Maybe you'll feed them before the nap, maybe not, it depends on the kid. That's kind of how the schedule goes throughout the day. If I need to run an errand....I just feed them before I leave and they'll either fall asleep on the way, or stay awake......either way, they're usually happy cause they're fed. Basically it's a round about schedule. They wake up, eat, nap around 2-3 hours later.....then about 2 hourse after that, they wake up, eat and take another nap 2-3 hours later....and so on and so on. But like I said, every child is different, and every parent is different. Some people need more structure and set time for things. Others need time for spontaneity, and spur of the moment errands. Whatever works for you and your little one. I know you'll do great. You're a great mom. It's overwhelming at times, but you do your best and the Lord makes up for the rest. Enjoy this time. I know it doesn't seem like it right now......but you're gonna look back and treasure these moments. Good Luck. Love ya.

Jill Rogers said...

Hey Whit! Well- Welcome to Motherhood! The day WILL come, it's just a matter of being patient enough for it. Grant slept about the same as Emily is at first, and now he's sleeping 12-14 hours a night :-) But, a word of caution: The American Academy of Pediatrics HIGHLY suggests not trying the hard core scheduling that Babywise suggests. I can't tell you how many infant development teachers would grill us not to try/use/read Babywise. I know it's hard, but they just don't have the neurological capabilities to keep a schedule like that, so in essence for those that try hard to schedule their feedings and refuse to feed the baby until the exact time (even if the baby is crying) they're just starving the baby until the MOM is ready. Then something about it makes them fussier because they feel like they have to be more vocal to have their needs met.

Grant would go in phases, as I'm sure most babies do. But if you're patient enough you'll start to recognized that she'll put HERSELF in a schedule. After a few months he would want to go down and eat around the same times of the day. The lack of sleep is HARD- But just remind yourself that "This too shall pass"- Meaning the phase. She'll grow and get more developed and neurologically ready. It's just a matter of patience.

GOOD LUCK!

Jill Rogers said...

Ok- Sorry, I was in a hurry with my last post and have actually had a chance to read the comments. But I do think it's important to clarify: Schedule vs. Routine. A ROUTINE is fabulous. Book, Singing, Kiss, Bed- Or bath, book, bed- WHATEVER you guys decide to do. Grant would usually go down without a hitch when we would do the same THING. For example, now his routine is going around the house and we'll close all the blinds and turn off all the lights, then he'll help us put his bottle in the microwave, then smooch everybody good night and he's good. But at Emily's age it's more going to be about feed, change, rock/sing- Bed. The key (as I've learned in multiple development classes) is to recognize when she's DROWSY. That's when you want to put her down so she learns to self-soothe. It's also helpful to have consistent ITEMS (binky/blanket).

But a set SCHEDULE is more beneficial for you than it is for her. While your emotional well-being is definitely important, it's also important to know that she's learning a LOT and EVEYTHING is new and she's developing and growing the fastest right now than she will her whole life. So expect things to be a little different every day until about 6 months or so. Then she'll be old enough to start being consistent on her own.

Ok- I swear- That's the end of my unsolicited advise. You'll work it out though, you're a great mom!

Anna said...

Wow! You have lots of great advice on here, but since every baby is different, I will go ahead and let you know what has worked best for me and my little Braden...

I also read Babywise and tried to follow their advice, but found that it just wasn't working for my little guy. I loved the idea of a schedule during those first few months, but he just wouldn't respond. I followed the same pattern. I made sure that every 2-3 hours he would eat, play, and sleep, but most of the time the order was all crazy.

Around 4-5 months Braden was really struggling with taking naps (sometimes he wouldn't nap at all), and settling down to bed at night. I talked to my pediatrician, and she suggested that I read the book Healthy Sleep Habits, Happy Child, by Marc Weissbluth. The book is written by a pediatrician that has studied sleep habits of young children. I loved the book because he gave you choices on how to approach sleeping training with your child. There are also lots of stories from parents he has worked with. The best part of his advice (which almost all of your friends has mentioned) is having a nap/bedtime routine. For each nap we do the same routine: change diaper, book, nurse, and sing. The bed time routine is the same, we just include a bath at the beginning, and a prayer with dad at the end. I wanted the routines to be the same, but I hoped the bath and prayer would signal that it was time to sleep for the night, not just an hour or two.

At nine months Braden has fallen into his own schedule. He eats, plays, and sleeps at approximately the same time each day. He takes 2 naps a day (for about an hour to an hour and a half, he is not a long napper, sigh) and is in bed between 6-7pm. I think an early bedtime is so important (I started an early bedtime around 5-6 months). No matter what time we put him to bed (6,7,8,9pm) he wakes up between 6-7am, but the earlier we put him to bed the happier he is when he wakes up. Don't let this scare you, but we are still working on sleeping through the night. I think it is just harder for some kids. Some nights he does it, and other nights he doesn't. When he does wake up it is just once (I know, I should probably let him cry, but I am so weak).

So there you have it. Do what is best for you, Emily, and Brad. Follow your heart. If you don't feel comfortable with something, don't do it, even if one of us says it is the only way. Right when you finally get it down, things change. It seems like we start all over again when a new developmental milestones occurs, we go out of town, he gets sick, etc. But don't worry, it will all fall into place. Cherish each moment, they grow so fast!

Heather said...

Hey whitney! so you've got tons of advice! So I guess I'll tell you what happened with mine cuz every kid is different, Cole had his days/nights mixed up so our whole day was trying to keep him awake so that we could at least get him to sleep at night.Then once we finally got that down(he still woke up every 2 hours to eat until he was 4 months...)we started to work on naps, we only put him down when he was EXTREMELY tired. That way he got a good nap. He took like 3 naps a day until he was about 6 months old then he went down to 2 naps a day then at about 14 months it was one nap a day.
Chloe is a different story...when it came to sleep she was a golden child but she has more attitude than I can handle, so you can't have it all... with Chloe I just wait till she starts showing signs that she's tired cuz if you put them down at the exact same time every single day and they really aren't that tired then they'll only sleep for like 15 minutes. Me, I would rather wait till they are way tired and have a LONG nap time for me....maybe that's selfish but you do what you gotta do!

Josh and Katy said...

Hey Whitney. I think that you CAN have the best of both worlds. If you enjoy rocking Emily to sleep and she likes it too, then by all means do it! You are not going to ruin her. :-) I rocked and sang Brock to sleep every night, and then when he was about 9 months old he grew out of it. He started becoming restless when we would try to rock him, so we started just laying him down. There was a little bit of crying the first night, a little less the second night, and then he was fine. He was at the age that he knew he was tired and just wanted to go to bed, so that is what he did. (Let me add here that I don't think I am a wonderful mom and that his good sleeping habits have anything at all to do with things I did- we would just kind of watch and learn as we went along.) Anyway, Brock's adjustment to put himself to sleep was quick and painless and he has kept the good habit ever since. We send him to bed and he lays there until he falls asleep. We are lucky to have such a good baby!
CAMDEN on the other hand :-) did not want to be rocked to sleep EVER! He would fight sleep with everything he had, and from about 1 month to about 4 months old he slept with us (something I had determined I would NEVER do!) because that was the only way to get him to stay asleep! But, just as Brock did, he grew restless and recognized his need for his own sleep space, so we started to put him down in his crib at night. He cried more than Brock did and still does every now and then, but he knows that his bed is where he sleeps and understands when he is tired. We use the same soft blanket every night for him, because he seemed to want something consistent and comforting, now that mom and dad weren't there. Moral of the story, here are two boys with the same parents yet very different sleep habits. I don't think you can find an answer in a book, although there is a lot of great advice from very qualified people in them and it doesn't hurt to look it over. But, what worked for us is learning to recognize the specific attitudes/preferences of each individual child. Everything is harder when you are tired- so just do what you have to do to get as much sleep as possible for you and Emily both. Good luck. You are a great mom- Emily is a lucky lucky girl. I hope this helps! Let us know how it all turns out.

Melissa said...

I've only had one baby, but I think he turned out all right as far as sleep goes. Sleep is a huge deal. I read babywise, and I followed it pretty closely, but I adapted it to what I was comfortable with, too. If it was naptime I would put him down, and then go in a couple of minutes later and pat him on the back to comfort him, and then leave. Repeat, Repeat. Repeat. It takes time and work to get them on a routine, but I think it is worth it! I never felt like his schedule was confining to me, it was actually empowering because I always knew what he needed. I never had to wonder is he hungry, is he tired, I always knew. I mean there is some guesswork still involved, but not nearly as much. It totally helped me to be a better mom because I was never frustrated about not knowing what my baby needed! It is so nice now, Tate will go to sleep on his own, or if I feel like rocking him for a long time he will still go right to bed afterwards. So whatever you decide, I would suggest doing some type of routine; I don't think you'll regret it!

Erin said...

"You're not alone!" - Imagine this sung by Michael McLean. Haha. I can't complain about Ellie sleeping at night. Half the time she sleeps 7-9 hours straight and the other half she wakes up only one time to eat. This started happening at 6 weeks, so dont get too discouraged yet! When she's four months I plan to let her cry it out when she wakes up at night. But she doesn't nap unless I'm holding her - and then she's a very light sleeper. All I have to say is, it gets better and somehow us first timers will figure all of this out! (I hope and pray).

camilla said...

Here's my experience: With Lily we started letting her cry it out at like 6 months. She was sleeping through the night at 9 months. We can't let Izzy cry it out due to shared walls. She is 14 months, and barely BARELY starting to sleep through the night. From what I've read, and I can't back it up with any quotes because I can't remember why now, but from all the books I read, I don't believe in letting your baby totally cry it out until they are about 5 months, I don't think they have the calming skills. They need the first few months to bond and develop trust w/us. Anyway, just my experiences. So, obviously, I'm a fan of crying out out, even though it's hard and sucks, and you cry it out outside the door with them.